Winter wishes from the Dorothy Day Guild

Casey Mullaney • Feb 02, 2024

Dear friends,


Greetings, and happy Feast of the Presentation! Today’s Gospel reading brings the Holy Family into the embrace of Anna and Simeon, faithful prophets who trusted that God would send them a redeemer, and who recognize the child Jesus in His mother’s arms as their long-awaited Savior. As we continue to await news of a miracle which will further Dorothy’s canonization cause, may we remain as prayerful and vigilant as Anna and Simeon, and as ready to welcome Christ in our neighbors, especially the poor.


Website Updates:

For those of us who study and work at schools and universities, the spring semester is in full swing! As I write this missive from the library at the University of Notre Dame, there’s a happy buzz of activity around the circulation desk, and I know of at least two professors on campus who have assigned texts by Dorothy to their classes this term. At the Guild, we’ve received a number of requests for recommended book lists for high school and college courses as well as personal enrichment for those who desire to deepen their engagement with Dorothy’s life and legacy and those who are meeting her for the first time. This past week, we added a selected bibliography page to the Guild’s website with purchase and reading links and a few recommendations to start you off. We’ll continue to update this page with annotations and additional works, but we were too excited to wait any longer to share it with you. Happy reading!

 

We’re continuing to develop our website to offer additional resources that you can use for your own learning and formation as well as to share Dorothy’s witness with others. Last year, our wonderful Manhattan College interns developed a beautiful and informative brochure that gives a brief introduction to Dorothy’s life and the history and aims of the Dorothy Day Guild. You can view the brochure on our Guild History page and download and print copies to share with your home communities for free! Thank you, Rebecca and Joanna, for your creative work designing this brochure and sourcing the text. Our thanks go as well to our co-chair, Deirdre Cornell, for the editorial guidance and mentorship she provided to our student interns who have given so much time and talent to the work of the Dorothy Day Guild this past year!


Events (ours and others):

Our Lenten book club begins next month! We’ve updated our events page to include more information about the reading group that Anne Klejment will host to read Dorothy’s spiritual autobiography, The Long Loneliness over four Sunday evenings in March. We were so pleased to receive so much interest last month, but as some of you noticed, we forgot to mention that this book club will meet online! Join us from anywhere from 8-9 pm Eastern/7-8 pm Central on March 3rd, 10th, 17th, and 24th to discuss this modern spiritual classic, guided by Anne’s historical expertise, and sign up here to receive the reading schedule, Zoom link, and additional materials.

If you want to spend time reading The Long Loneliness in community with other seekers this spring, but Sunday nights don’t work for you, we also learned that the Spiritual Renewal Center in Syracuse, NY is hosting a Wednesday evening reading group from 4-5 pm Eastern time. You can join them online or in person at 1342 Lancaster Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210. There is no need to RSVP, but you can call them at 315-472-6546 for further information. It’s great to see such widespread interest in Dorothy’s life and writing!

 

We also learned of two other events which we think you might be interested in checking out, both taking place on Saturday, April 13th (we hate to make you choose!). The Hank Center for the Catholic Intellectual Heritage at Loyola University Chicago is hosting a Peter Maurin conference to examine the life and work of Dorothy’s beloved mentor and friend. The organizers write that Peter’s “program of action consisted of roundtable discussions for the clarification of thought, houses of hospitality where the works of mercy could be performed, and agronomic universities... These topics will be discussed in a roundtable, personalist way-- in the spirit of Peter Maurin.” The event is free and open to the public, so if you’re local to the Midwest, we hope you can attend!

 

For those in the Northeast, the Center at Mariandale is hosting a day-long conference entitled “Revolution of the Heart: The Spirituality of Dorothy Day” to explore questions such as “How does her radical spirituality – grounded in volunteer poverty, non-violence, eucharistic devotion, and activism – speak to people of this day and age?” and “How might she be a wisdom figure in the contemporary world which is often deemed as secular, materialistic, and techno-centered?” This conference will feature Guild advisory committee members Martha Hennessy and Robert Ellsberg as guest speakers and is co-sponsored by our friends at Manhattan College. 

 

We hate to present you with such a tough decision, but we know both conferences will be fabulous spaces for fellowship, learning, and clarification of thought!


Further reading recommendations:

We’d like to draw your attention to a few new pieces which have come out since we wrote to you last month. Today is the Feast of the Presentation of the Lord, also known in some parts of the world as Candlemas. This feast, which comes forty days after the Nativity of the Lord, marks the final day of the Christmas and Epiphany season. All good things come to end (for this liturgical year, anyway), but we do have one last Christmas reflection to share with you! Luke Stocking writes at the Canadian Catholic Register on the spiritual necessity of rest and contemplation, and Dorothy as an exemplar of the active-contemplative vocation. He writes, 

“If I take time out from my work to enjoy a book, or share good food and fun with my family, it is because I desire these same things for the whole world. If I create time for prayer and reflection to be in the presence of God, it is because I dream of a world where everyone has an experience of that same presence. My retreats and times of rest are reflections of the world I want.”

You can read his column, "Basket of adorables by basking in God," on the Canadian Catholic Register’s website.

 

We also loved this opinion piece from the Des Moines Register, "You and I have responsibility to the immigrant and the refugee" by professor and community mobilizer Jason Lief. So often in contemporary political discourse, we throw around phrases like “personal responsibility” and concepts like subsidiarity to deny our mutual belonging to the Mystical Body of Christ. Dorothy, however, “discovered in Catholic social teaching [a] call to take responsibility for our brothers and sisters — for our neighbors — because every human being is created in the image of God and endowed with dignity, not because of anything they do or don’t do, but simply because they are loved by God.” Dorothy’s anarchist ethos is one of deep commitment which reminds us that “caring for the immigrant and refugee in this country is not the responsibility of the government, nor is it the responsibility of the church. Caring for the immigrant and refugee is our responsibility — yours and mine.” 

 

Thanks Jason, for this powerful and timely reminder. In this season when so many people around the world have been forced from their homes by armed conflict, climate change, and dearth of opportunity, we can remember that Jesus shared these experiences during his life on earth. On this last day of a long and generous Christmas season, let’s ask Dorothy to help us take up our responsibility and remember that when we welcome our immigrant and refugee brothers and sisters, we welcome Jesus.

 

Finally, we are so pleased to share a beautiful piece recently published in the liturgical magazine Adoremus, by Catholic Worker and Dorothy Day Guild advisory committee member Carmina Chapp. "Dorothy Day: Faithful Daughter of the Church-- Faithful to the Prayer of the Church" is a rich exploration of Dorothy’s sacramental devotion and the Benedictine charism of prayer and work in which Dorothy found a spiritual home. Dorothy’s radical witness was sustained by a rich prayer life grounded in the liturgies of the Church. As Carmina writes, “Day’s commitment to the liturgical practice of the Church empowered her to boldly spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ in both word and action. Catholic doctrine and social teaching permeated everything she did.”


At the Dorothy Day Guild, we have often said that Dorothy is “a saint for our time.” Dorothy’s spiritual and moral commitment to nonviolence, voluntary poverty, and hospitality has refreshed and re-presented the Gospel for so many of us, enabling us to see the life of Christ for what it truly is– Good News. Dorothy does not stand alone at some point in the past. Her witness compels something from us in the present. “The point of her life, however, was to show that every human being not only is called to be holy, but actually can be holy, by the grace of God—grace obtained in the participation of the sacraments,” Carmina writes. Dorothy “was convinced that Catholicism radically lived is the only answer to our human misery.” Many thanks, Carmina, for sharing such a fine work of scholarship and personal reflection with our readers!


Prayer Requests:

Dorothy’s deep prayer life was the source of incredible graces and blessings for her friends and family, the wide network of Catholic Worker communities, and the poor in her neighborhood and beyond during her time on earth. That legacy of loving intercession has continued after her death, and we invite you to invoke Dorothy in your own prayers on behalf of your own communities. We have received a few prayer requests from friends and members of the Dorothy Day Guild this month, including from our friend Mike Doyle in Tampa. Mike’s brother-in-law, Joe, is currently recovering from serious cardiac complications. Thankfully, his health is improving each day! Please pray for Joe’s continued healing and for his family and caregivers in this time.

 

We were also saddened to learn of Dr. Carol Berrigan’s death last month in Syracuse, NY. Carol was the wife of Jerry Berrigan and sister-in-law to Fr. Dan Berrigan and Philip Berrigan. A lifelong activist for peace and a just and inclusive education for students with disabilities, Carol leaves behind four children, five grandchildren, five great-grandchildren, and hundreds of former students and friends whose lives she touched through her decades of faithful witness to the heart of the Gospel. Through Dorothy’s intercession, please pray for the repose of Carol’s soul and the comfort of all those who miss her.

Dorothy was a close friend and ally of the extended Berrigan family and visited Jerry, Phil, and Dan’s mother Frida on her visit to Syracuse in 1971. A page from her diary in May of 1971 includes Carol and Jerry’s phone number, so perhaps they also hosted her in their home on that visit– many thanks to Alex Avitabile for finding this note. When I lived in Syracuse as a Jesuit volunteer, I attended St. Lucy’s parish with Jerry and Carol; it was humbling to be in the presence of such gentle, great-souled people, Learning of the long-standing friendships and the depth of solidarity which have undergirded Catholic anti-war activism since the first years of the Catholic Worker movement has been truly awe-inspiring, and my personal prayer is that Dorothy would now lend her strength to raising up and forming the next generation of peacemakers in the Church.


A few words from Dorothy:

As I considered Dorothy’s many long-standing friendships, the religious and activist networks she was part of, and the hundreds of stories that intersected with her own, it really struck me how significantly that web of relationship and solidarity extends into our own time and invites our participation. I have always loved this photograph of Dorothy seated with Coretta Scott King and Cesar Chavez: an image of multiracial, spiritually-grounded love in service of the common good. Dorothy had an incredible gift for building relationships, understanding every person she met as a member or potential member of the Mystical Body of Christ. Dorothy likewise had a gift for identifying holiness in the people with whom she stood in solidarity, even those who were different from her and with whom she sometimes disagreed. In Dorothy's February 1971 column, she spoke about Angela Davis, who was at the time a young, incarcerated activist. In this column, Dorothy wrote:

Underneath a picture of Angela Davis which appeared in the “Daily World” a few weeks ago, there was a caption, “All generations shall call her blessed.” To continue to quote scripture, she has been “counted worthy to suffer dishonor” for justice sake. Angela Davis is a Communist, in this case and it is a name for vilification nowadays, though the early Christians, working for the common good became communists in a very literal sense. “Property, the more common it becomes, the more holy it becomes,” as St. Gertrude said in the middle ages.

 

That quotation from the Magnificat used by the Communist daily, reminded me of the Scottsboro case during the Depression, when we were all fighting the death sentences of nine black youths in the South. I used the headline on the front page of The Catholic Worker “The Scottsboro Boys are the Children of Mary,” which is the name of a pious association for youth in the Catholic Church. This caused great controversy among our readers although I explained in the body of the text that they should read in John’s Gospel how Jesus from the Cross, called out to Mary, his mother, “Behold thy son,” and to the apostle John, “Behold thy mother.” The Gospel account continues, “and from that time, the apostle took her for his own.” So we are all children of Mary.

 

Certainly in the light of this teaching, since Christ is our brother, Angela Davis is our sister, and we love and esteem her as such. We cannot and must not prejudge her case any more than we can the case against Fathers Phil and Dan Berrigan.

 

Angela Davis is a beautiful young woman, a graduate of Brandeis University, and at a time when jobs even in the academic field were scarce, risked her livelihood by openly stating her faith in the kind of social order which she thought would bring justice and a better life for her black brothers and sisters.

Dorothy, although not herself a communist, honored Angela’s dedication to the common good, and her willingness to put her individual good on the line for the sake of the poor. Dorothy likewise took a different view of nonviolent direct action than the Berrigans and other Plowshares activists, but she recognized in them an unshakable commitment to conscience and to active love for their most vulnerable neighbors.

 

Later in this same column, Dorothy tells us that Sister Donald Corcoran went to the Women’s House of Detention, where Dorothy herself had been incarcerated, to keep vigil on Angela’s behalf in the snow and sleet during the Christmas season. Sister Donald currently serves as a member of our advisory committee from her monastery in Windsor, New York, and Angela Davis, who celebrated her 8oth birthday last month, has continued her activist work from her home in California. These women and men, activists and peacemakers, are not part of the past, but the present. Their lives intersected with Dorothy’s and with each other’s, making a web of solidarity which reaches across the country and across the globe, back and forth through the generations. If you are reading this letter, you are part of that web, too. Our prayer at the Guild is that you continue to be drawn more deeply into relationships of committed love and solidarity, and that God’s grace sustains you as you live out your own vocation to care for and tend the common good.

 

In peace,

Dr. Casey Mullaney, on behalf of the Dorothy Day Guild

Share this post

By Claire Schaeffer-Duffy and Scott Schaeffer-Duffy 26 Apr, 2024
Sharing life with the poor in crowded row houses in a neighborhood where crack cocaine flowed freely was not for everyone. It was eventually not for us. One night at dinner, Carl noted that every man at the table had punched him or Scott at least once. The mayhem we once found exhilarating now exhausted us. Like many Catholic Worker couples, we fell in love while working at the houses. We got married in Washington, DC in 1984 on the feast of a married saint, Thomas More, and then moved to Worcester, Massachusetts. We found a cheap apartment and took jobs that gave us flexibility to focus on anti-nuclear activism. To keep life simple, we decided to do no hospitality. That decision did not hold. Shortly after our first child, Justin, was born, Scott served a thirty-day jail sentence for a protest against nuclear weapons. While in jail, he met an inmate who was due to be released before Christmas. Since Kenny had nowhere to go, we took him into our apartment until he could get settled. Hosting him reminded us that we liked the Catholic Worker’s unique combination of the works of mercy with the works of peace and justice. Together with three friends, we spent several months in prayer and discussion to discern the possibility of forming an intentional community. As part of our discernment, we gradually began to incorporate Catholic Worker practices. We ate together weekly and joined a local vigil against nuclear weapons. Inspired by the journalism of Dorothy Day, we began publishing the Catholic Radical, a newsletter that continues to this day. In the summer of 1986, our family moved into a large inner-city apartment with Dan Ethier and Sarah Jeglosky and started the Saints Francis & Thérèse Catholic Worker. 
By Carolyn Zablotny 26 Apr, 2024
Bro. Martin Erspamer, OSB and Bro. Michael (Mickey) McGrath, OSFS are both liturgical artists, widely recognized for their creative work. Meeting in the pages of the Guild’s newsletter, they bring an artistry and open-heartedness long associated with Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker.
By Gabriella Wilke 26 Apr, 2024
Gabriella Wilke : Dorothy Day believed that the only answer to loneliness in this life is community. You have responded to the call, living as a member of the Bruderhof. What sparked your passion for community?
More Posts
Share by: